Andrew Boff quits Tories after ECHR rule blocks mayoral bid
Long-serving London Assembly Member Andrew Boff left the Conservatives after being barred from running for London mayor over his support for the European Convention on Human Rights. His case shows how a national party rule on the convention now shapes who can stand at City Hall.
- Andrew Boff left the Conservative Party in October after 53 years as a member.
- He says he was blocked from seeking the Tory London mayoral nomination over his support for the ECHR.
- Kemi Badenoch has said all Tory candidates must back leaving the European Convention on Human Rights.
- A London Assembly paper records that Mr Boff now sits as an independent, ungrouped Member.
What happened
Andrew Boff, a long-serving London Assembly Member who had been in the Conservative Party for 53 years, says he was stopped from seeking the party’s nomination for London mayor because he supports the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). He told the Local Democracy Reporting Service he left the party immediately in late October after being barred from the race.
Mr Boff said the rule requiring candidates to back leaving the ECHR was originally aimed at parliamentary hopefuls and questioned why it applied to the London mayoral contest. He described it as a “purity test”, argued that the convention had Winston Churchill’s backing, and noted that only Russia has left it. He said he had not changed his views, but that the party had become “really quite authoritarian” under Kemi Badenoch.
Kemi Badenoch set out the ECHR rule at the Conservative conference in Manchester, following a review by Tory peer Lord Wolfson. She said anyone who does not agree with leaving the convention “should not and cannot stand as a Conservative candidate”. A London Assembly paper now lists Mr Boff as an independent, ungrouped Member after his resignation from the City Hall Conservatives Group.
Mr Boff says he would return to the Conservatives if the party changed its stance on the ECHR. If not, he plans to stand again for the Assembly as an independent. He has rejected calls to quit and trigger a by-election. Emma Best, deputy leader of the City Hall Conservatives, has said he should do so, while group leader Susan Hall thanked him for his work and restated the group’s support for leaving the ECHR.
Why it matters
Mr Boff’s departure shows how a national Conservative rule on the ECHR now reaches into London politics. A test first set for MPs is deciding who can run for mayor and has already led to a long-serving Assembly Member leaving the party and its group at City Hall. His comparison with Russia highlights the scale of the shift: Russia is the only state to have left the convention, doing so in September 2022 after quitting the Council of Europe.
The context
- At the Conservative conference in Manchester, Kemi Badenoch said anyone who does not agree with leaving the ECHR 'should not and cannot stand as a Conservative candidate'. The move followed a review of the issue by the Tory peer Lord Wolfson.
- Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn called Ms Badenoch's ECHR stance 'utterly irresponsible'. Sinn Féin said it was 'very worrying'.
- A London Assembly paper records that Andrew Boff resigned from the City Hall Conservatives Group and now sits as an independent, ungrouped Member.
- Russia stopped being a party to the European Convention on Human Rights on 16 September 2022, six months after it left the Council of Europe.
- The Council of Europe's Secretary General said Russia's exit left more than 140 million Russian citizens without the convention's protection.