Sussex police officers sacked over force used on 92-year-old man
Two Sussex Police constables have been dismissed for gross misconduct over their use of a Taser, baton and Pava spray on 92-year-old care home resident Donald Burgess. The case shows how officers can be cleared in a criminal court but still lose their jobs and be barred from policing.
What happened
Two Sussex Police officers, PC Stephen Smith and PC Rachel Comotto, have been dismissed without notice for gross misconduct over their handling of 92-year-old care home resident Donald Burgess in St Leonards, East Sussex. Mr Burgess, a wheelchair user with an amputated leg, was in his room holding a cutlery knife when officers attended the home on 21 June 2022 after reports that a resident was threatening staff.
A misconduct panel found that within about 90 seconds of entering the room, PC Smith used Pava spray on Mr Burgess and struck his arm with a baton, while PC Comotto discharged a Taser at him. The panel ruled that the force used was inappropriate and excessive. On the same day, PC Comotto also posted a disparaging comment about care homes on Facebook, which was considered as a separate misconduct allegation.
Mr Burgess was taken to hospital, where he later caught Covid-19 and died on 13 July 2022, aged 93. A pathologist concluded that the officers’ actions did not cause or contribute to his death. Both officers have now been placed on the College of Policing’s barred list, which prevents them from working for any police force or certain policing bodies.
How our readers reacted
The story drew 533 comments on our platforms, mostly critical of the officers’ actions and focused on police accountability and misconduct. Around 59% of reactions were negative, 33% neutral and 8% positive. Readers mainly discussed how police behave towards vulnerable people and what punishments officers should face, and asked why the officers were not convicted, what happened to Mr Burgess, and whether there would be compensation.
Why it matters
Many people have questioned how the officers could be sacked after being cleared in court. PCs Smith and Comotto were charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm and found not guilty by a jury at Southwark Crown Court in May 2025. That criminal trial tested whether a crime was proved beyond reasonable doubt. The later misconduct hearing applied professional standards of behaviour, a different test that can still lead to dismissal even after an acquittal. Being added to the barred list means the officers cannot work in policing or for oversight bodies, and can only ask for their names to be removed after at least five years. Their case is one of 735 officer dismissals in England and Wales in 2024–25, showing how such sanctions fit into the wider system of police discipline.
The context
- PCs Stephen Smith and Rachel Comotto were charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm after the Crown Prosecution Service authorised charges in March 2024. A jury found them not guilty in May 2025.
- Mr Burgess died in hospital on 13 July 2022, aged 93. A pathologist concluded that the officers' actions did not cause or contribute to his death.
- After the trial, the IOPC said both officers would face gross misconduct hearings over their use of force. PC Comotto faced an extra allegation over social media comments about the incident.
- People on the College of Policing barred list cannot be employed by police forces, police and crime commissioners, the IOPC or HM Inspectorate of Constabulary. Those dismissed for gross misconduct can apply for removal after at least five years.
- Between 1 April 2024 and 31 March 2025, 735 regular police officers in England and Wales were dismissed, together with 31 special constables and 280 police staff.
Readers mostly talked about police accountability and police behavior.
Readers are talking about this story under our posts. Add your view.