Uxbridge knife attacker given indefinite hospital order after killing street cleaner
Uber driver Dawood Safi, 28, has been given an indefinite hospital order after killing council street cleaner Wayne Broadhurst and stabbing two others in Uxbridge. Psychiatrists found he was suffering from psychotic depression with delusions, and prosecutors accepted manslaughter by diminished responsibility.
What happened
Uber driver Dawood Safi, 28, has been given an indefinite hospital order for killing 49-year-old council street cleaner Wayne Broadhurst in Uxbridge, west London. The attacks took place on 27 October 2025 around Midhurst Gardens, where Safi lived. Police were called shortly before 5pm.
Safi stabbed his landlord, 45-year-old Shahzad Farrukh, several times in the neck, back and chest, puncturing his lung and leaving him with life-changing injuries. He then fatally stabbed Mr Broadhurst, who prosecutors described as a dog walker who was out at the time. A teenage boy was also stabbed but his injuries were not life-threatening.
Safi was first charged with murder. At Southwark Crown Court on 13 July 2026 he admitted manslaughter by diminished responsibility. On 16 July a jury convicted him of the attempted murder of his landlord. The jury could not reach a verdict on a second attempted murder charge relating to the teenage boy, but Safi had already admitted assault occasioning actual bodily harm. He was held in a secure hospital until sentencing, which was listed for 5 October 2026.
How our readers reacted
One reader commented on the story and six people liked it. The reaction focused on the crime itself rather than the legal or medical details of the case.
Why it matters
The hospital order means Safi will receive psychiatric treatment in a secure hospital instead of a fixed prison term. Four psychiatrists assessed him and diagnosed psychotic depression with delusional beliefs, concluding this significantly affected his judgement and self-control. Prosecutors accepted the manslaughter plea only after these findings. According to the Crown Prosecution Service, Safi had approached a GP, a hospital, the police and his landlord before the attack with concerns driven by his delusions. This raises questions about how different services respond when people present with serious mental health symptoms that may pose a risk to themselves or others, and what opportunities there are to intervene earlier in similar cases.
The context
- Four psychiatrists assessed Safi and diagnosed psychotic depression with delusional beliefs. They concluded this substantially impaired his ability to form rational judgements and to exercise self-control.
- According to the CPS, before the attack Safi had gone to a GP, a hospital, the police and his landlord with concerns that came from his delusions.
- Safi admitted manslaughter by diminished responsibility on 13 July 2026. On 16 July a jury at Southwark Crown Court convicted him of the attempted murder of his landlord. It could not reach a verdict on a second attempted murder charge relating to a teenage boy.
- Police were called to Midhurst Gardens, Uxbridge, at 16:55 on 27 October 2025. A 45-year-old man suffered life-changing injuries and a teenage boy suffered injuries that were not life-threatening.
Readers mostly talked about reaction to crime.